Red Train Blog

Ramblings to the left

The Red Train Blog is a left leaning politics blog, which mainly focuses on British politics and is written by two socialists. We are Labour Party members, for now, and are concerned about issues such as inequality, nationalisation, housing, the NHS and peace. What you will find here is a discussion of issues that affect the Labour Party, the wider left and politics as a whole.

  • Home
  • Topics
    • Topics
    • EU referendum
    • The Crisis in the Labour Party
  • Art
  • Books
  • About us
  • Search

Saying Gary Lineker should lose his job over a tweet is biased, after what Andrew Neil and Jeremy Clarkson got away with

March 14, 2023 by Alastair J R Ball in Political narratives

Conservatives are defending free speech. Gone are concerns about insulting god or Jesus.  The right is defending the freedom to scream abuse into someone’s face. Don’t like it? Then you must be a snowflake.

Of course, the right’s support of free speech is not universal. Toby Young and his Free Speech Union hasn’t rushed to the defence of Gary Lineker after he was cancelled by the BBC for expressing his opinion of the government. The Tory politicians and culture warriors, keen to accuse the left of being against free speech, were very keen to suppress Lineker’s free speech when he said something they didn’t like. 

Similarly, the brigade who defended peoples’ right to offend others, when those being offended were Muslims and trans people, get pretty offended when you criticise the government or soldiers or patriots. They then seek to cancel the offender as much as possible.

Moonlighting for the right

There is a clear hypocrisy in how Lineker has been treated. He tweeted his opinion from his own Twitter account and has faced consequences for it. These are now rescinded because these consequences detonated the sport of football for a weekend and people noticed.

Meanwhile, Andrew Neil was able to be chairman of the Spectator (a publication that positions itself slightly to the right of Ivan the Terrible) whilst working in BBC news, and this was considered fine. Jeremy Clarkson was allowed to write a column in The Sun at the same time as hosting Top Gear, which no one minded. Not even when he claimed on The One Show that striking workers should be shot in front of their families.

My view is that, when not on the BBC’s time, people should be allowed to say, write or tweet whatever they want. If Neil wants to moonlight for the Spectator that’s fine, but Lineker can tweet whatever he likes about the government. The problem with this position - or whatever the actual BBC position on impartiality is - is that it isn’t being consistently enforced. This is bias.

Soapboxing on how nasty the Tories are

The Clarkson case is worse. Not only was Clarkson able to voice his views on the BBC’s One Show, he was able to use his supposedly impartial BBC general car themed entertainment show to slam London Mayor Ken Livingston over bendy buses and whatever else was grinding Clarkson’s gears that week.

If this is allowed, then surely Lineker can tweet about politics on this private Twitter account. It’s not like he’s soapboxing on how nasty the Tories are in between the highlights of the Leicester/Arsenal match before turning to Ian Wright (or someone else I vaguely remember from collecting football stickers in the 90s) for his opinion.

Don’t listen to Joe Rogan

We should allow for as much freedom as possible in our laws, whilst using the power of the state to constrain speech only in the case where it is causing harm. That’s the legal argument for free speech, which I laid out in a previous post. However, the issue of free speech extends beyond what’s allowed under law.

I previously wrote that Joe Rogan shouldn’t face legal consequences for allowing Dr Robert Malone on his podcast and spreading anti-vaccine nonsense, but I wouldn’t recommend listening to his podcast where the ill-informed are allowed to say whatever they like, confidently and without push back.

Similarly, if you don’t like what Lineker said then don’t watch Match of the Day or follow him on Twitter. I hear there are other football shows and Twitter feeds out there.

Muzzling people you disagree with

What Lineker faced was clearly disproportionate and unfair. It’s not fair that conservatives get away with a lot more, especially when what they’re saying isn’t going out via the BBC itself (as in the case of Lineker’s tweet).

Also, if you think that Ricky Gervais or Dave Chappelle should be able to say whatever they want about trans people and face no push back, but Lineker should lose his job for exercising his free speech, then it’s time to admit you just want to muzzle people you disagree with.

That is also not defending free speech. The left are supposedly snowflakes and against free speech, but the right is pretty keen on shutting up anyone they disagree with. What happened to Lineker shows that there are many on the right who want to silence anyone who disagrees with them. Defenders of free speech my arse, is all I say to that.

Related posts
Political narratives
How should the left view the porn industry?
Political narratives
Political narratives
Books.jpg
Political narratives
Behold the smartest people in the room: The Waterstones Dads
Political narratives
Political narratives
Political narratives
Russell Brand isn’t the only person on the hippy to alt-right pipeline and the left should be aware of this
Political narratives
Political narratives
March 14, 2023 /Alastair J R Ball
Political narratives
  • Newer
  • Older

Powered by Squarespace

Related posts
Trump-rally.jpg
Jun 20, 2025
Elon Musk and Donald Trump: The Beavis and Butt-Head of right-wing edge lords
Jun 20, 2025
Jun 20, 2025
Capitalism.jpg
May 27, 2025
“That’s Your GDP”: Labour’s big growth delusion
May 27, 2025
May 27, 2025
nigel farage.jpg
May 15, 2025
Nigel Farage is seriously uncool
May 15, 2025
May 15, 2025
Keir_Starmer.jpg
May 13, 2025
Labour’s plan to defeat Farage by becoming him
May 13, 2025
May 13, 2025
Apr 12, 2025
How should the left view the porn industry?
Apr 12, 2025
Apr 12, 2025
8644221853_6af3ffe732_c.jpg
Apr 6, 2025
With welfare cuts Starmer’s Labour is grabbing the Tory spade and digging deeper
Apr 6, 2025
Apr 6, 2025
Books.jpg
Mar 28, 2025
Behold the smartest people in the room: The Waterstones Dads
Mar 28, 2025
Mar 28, 2025
Ukraine-flag.jpg
Mar 13, 2025
Austerity, military spending and Trump’s temper: the war in Ukraine continues
Mar 13, 2025
Mar 13, 2025
Feb 23, 2025
Has cool really abandoned Left Britannia?
Feb 23, 2025
Feb 23, 2025
Feb 18, 2025
Russell Brand isn’t the only person on the hippy to alt-right pipeline and the left should be aware of this
Feb 18, 2025
Feb 18, 2025