Red Train Blog

Ramblings to the left

The Red Train Blog is a left leaning politics blog, which mainly focuses on British politics and is written by two socialists. We are Labour Party members, for now, and are concerned about issues such as inequality, nationalisation, housing, the NHS and peace. What you will find here is a discussion of issues that affect the Labour Party, the wider left and politics as a whole.

  • Home
  • Topics
    • Topics
    • EU referendum
    • The Crisis in the Labour Party
  • Art
  • Books
  • About us
  • Search
polling-station.jpg

Do young people’s votes matter?

December 08, 2020 by Alastair J R Ball in Identity politics

Sage, the government’s scientific advisory group, has issued a stark warning about the effects of the pandemic on young people. Children’s schooling has been disrupted. Students have been locked down at universities. Retail and hospitality jobs, overwhelmingly staffed by young people, have been devastated by the pandemic.

The report warns of a lost generation, which reminds me of the previous time we were warned about a lost generation: when the 2008 financial crash wiped out the prospects of a different generation of young people.

Despite getting very little credit for it, young people have sacrificed so much to protect their predominantly retired elders (their job prospects; their independence, their university experiences; their relationships). Irresponsible parties or raves are very much the outliers. Young people, like all age groups, are generally following lockdown rules. They are also more likely to recognise government failings in managing covid, whereas older people are more likely to blame ‘the public’.

Appealing to this government’s conscience to help young people will not work. This government has figured out that it can do whatever it likes to young people and it won’t make any difference. Young people didn’t vote for this government and the Tories don’t care about anything apart from inflaming the culture wars that keep older, socially conservative Brexit voters mad and voting Tory.

Winning over older voters

Young people like me didn’t vote for this government. Older people voted for this government. Older Brexit voters switching from Labour to Conservative was a major factor in Boris Johnson winning the largest majority in more than ten years. Young people like me (by which I mean anyone under 45, the age at which party affiliation flips) have clustered together in cities either to go to university or because that’s where the jobs are. Whatever party young people vote for it will only affect a handful of seats and thus the interests of young people can be safely ignored.

Just take a look at Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership of the Labour Party. Corbyn was very popular amongst young voters like me. I, and many other people like me, were tired of different forms of bland centrism. Corbyn offered the chance to broaden the political debate.

However, Corbyn’s lack of patriotism and reluctance to commit to annihilating millions of people in a nuclear war was a major turn off for older voters. Offending some Boomers’ sense of patriotism massively outweighed inspiring millions of young people, and thus led to a huge electoral defeat for Labour.

A commitment to young people

I can see why tactically older voters are more valuable than young ones. However, I’m disappointed by Labour’s failure to stand up for young voters. Young people have to deal with insecure employment, bad housing, low wages and are looking at being the first generation to be worse off than their parents across their lifetime. All we can see from Labour is reassurance that Keir Starmer supports our troops.

How about a commitment to improving the housing situation, from Labour? Or tackling the looming environmental apocalypse? No, that would be the sort of thing young people want, definitely not the sort of thing that wins votes. I’m not sure who Keir Starmer’s Labour is supposed to appeal to, but it’s definitely not young people.

A mass defection of young voters

I would say that all young people should spurn Labour for The Green Party or for some other party (except the Lib Dems, we’ve seen where that gets us), however, it would make little difference. Young people are clustered together in cities where Labour has huge majorities. Even a mass defection of young voters to the Greens is unlikely to make any difference to Labour.

Boomers living in Tory/Labour swing seats have a much greater impact on elections and thus politics is catered towards them, with parties falling over each other to be tough on immigration and to be seen as on their side in the culture war. The First Past The Post voting system means that in seats with large Labour majorities, the party can afford to lose the votes of lots of young people.

A tale of two constituencies

My own constituency of Walthamstow is the sort of place that young, left-wing, socially liberal people live. We have craft beer bars, pop-up restaurants and a chronic housing shortage. Our MP Stella Creasy has been the MP since the 2010 General Election. In the 2019 General Election, she won 36,784 votes or 76% of the votes. That’s a majority of 30,862. The Tories came second in 2019, with less than 6,000 votes. If 10,000 young people switched from Labour to the Greens as a protest about how Labour is ignoring young voters, it would be a 577% increase in the Green vote but, Labour would still have a majority of 20,862, making that huge Green surge pointless.

Meanwhile in Bolsover in Derbyshire, where they have working men’s’ clubs and deindustrialization, we see how crucial a few voters are. Bolsover is the sort of place that young people leave to find work elsewhere and Boomers live in larger numbers. In 2019 the Tories elected their first-ever MP to this seat since it was created in 1950. The Tory majority is only 5,299 votes. Labour being seen as unpatriotic or relaxed about immigration can make all the difference in this seat. This is where the votes matter. 

Not just an age divide

Of course, young people are not all the same. Young people’s views differ by race, class, location and who they vote for just as they do for every other voting demographic. I’m sure that there are young people in Bolsover who didn’t like Corbyn’s perceived lack of patriotism and don’t like social liberalism, are hostile to Black Lives Matter and not fussed about the environment.

I know that in Walthamstow, there are Boomers that care passionately about social justice, the fate of the planet and the problems affecting young people. The country is divided by more than age alone. There’s an education divide, a wealth divide, a geographic divide and a values divide.

However, it’s a depressing future for young people, whilst politics is geared so much towards the old. Especially the old who live in specific places, care about a specific set of issues and have a specific set of values. Reports like this one should be a wake-up call for politicians to help the young, but I fear it will fall on deaf ears.

Polling station image taken by Rachel H and used under creative commons.

Related posts
Trump-rally.jpg
Jun 20, 2025
Elon Musk and Donald Trump: The Beavis and Butt-Head of right-wing edge lords
Jun 20, 2025
Jun 20, 2025
Capitalism.jpg
May 27, 2025
“That’s Your GDP”: Labour’s big growth delusion
May 27, 2025
May 27, 2025
nigel farage.jpg
May 15, 2025
Nigel Farage is seriously uncool
May 15, 2025
May 15, 2025
Keir_Starmer.jpg
May 13, 2025
Labour’s plan to defeat Farage by becoming him
May 13, 2025
May 13, 2025
Apr 12, 2025
How should the left view the porn industry?
Apr 12, 2025
Apr 12, 2025
8644221853_6af3ffe732_c.jpg
Apr 6, 2025
With welfare cuts Starmer’s Labour is grabbing the Tory spade and digging deeper
Apr 6, 2025
Apr 6, 2025
Books.jpg
Mar 28, 2025
Behold the smartest people in the room: The Waterstones Dads
Mar 28, 2025
Mar 28, 2025
Ukraine-flag.jpg
Mar 13, 2025
Austerity, military spending and Trump’s temper: the war in Ukraine continues
Mar 13, 2025
Mar 13, 2025
Feb 23, 2025
Has cool really abandoned Left Britannia?
Feb 23, 2025
Feb 23, 2025
Feb 18, 2025
Russell Brand isn’t the only person on the hippy to alt-right pipeline and the left should be aware of this
Feb 18, 2025
Feb 18, 2025
December 08, 2020 /Alastair J R Ball
Identity politics
  • Newer
  • Older

Powered by Squarespace

Related posts
Trump-rally.jpg
Jun 20, 2025
Elon Musk and Donald Trump: The Beavis and Butt-Head of right-wing edge lords
Jun 20, 2025
Jun 20, 2025
Capitalism.jpg
May 27, 2025
“That’s Your GDP”: Labour’s big growth delusion
May 27, 2025
May 27, 2025
nigel farage.jpg
May 15, 2025
Nigel Farage is seriously uncool
May 15, 2025
May 15, 2025
Keir_Starmer.jpg
May 13, 2025
Labour’s plan to defeat Farage by becoming him
May 13, 2025
May 13, 2025
Apr 12, 2025
How should the left view the porn industry?
Apr 12, 2025
Apr 12, 2025
8644221853_6af3ffe732_c.jpg
Apr 6, 2025
With welfare cuts Starmer’s Labour is grabbing the Tory spade and digging deeper
Apr 6, 2025
Apr 6, 2025
Books.jpg
Mar 28, 2025
Behold the smartest people in the room: The Waterstones Dads
Mar 28, 2025
Mar 28, 2025
Ukraine-flag.jpg
Mar 13, 2025
Austerity, military spending and Trump’s temper: the war in Ukraine continues
Mar 13, 2025
Mar 13, 2025
Feb 23, 2025
Has cool really abandoned Left Britannia?
Feb 23, 2025
Feb 23, 2025
Feb 18, 2025
Russell Brand isn’t the only person on the hippy to alt-right pipeline and the left should be aware of this
Feb 18, 2025
Feb 18, 2025